District Court, D. Minnesota March 16, 1994, 3-91-526 (Shell v. Amalgamated Cotton Garment)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-03-1994

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

KYLE, District Judge.

Introduction

Before the Court are (1) Plaintiffs Bash Shell and Marlene Shell’s (collectively, the “Shells”) Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, and (2) defendants Amalgamated Cotton Garment and Allied Industries Fund (the “Fund”) and Amalgamated Life Insurance’s (“ALI”) Motion for Summary Judgment. The two motions are cross-motions for summary judgment; resolving them will comprise a final determination of the issues in dispute.

1

Background

This matter was before the Court in September of 1992 on the Shells’ Motion for Summary Judgment. The Court assumes familiarity with the factual background of the dispute; hence, except as set forth below, none will be provided.

The Fund provides health and hospital benefits to participants and their dependents according to a schedule contained in the plan document setting forth the terms and conditions of the benefit plan (the “Plan Document”). The Plan Document contains a subrogation provision which provides:

When benefits are paid to or for an Employee or a Dependent under the terms of this plan, the Fund shall be subrogated to the right of recovery of such Employee or Dependent against any person or entity who is liable for the injury that necessitated the hospitalization or the medical or the surgical treatment for which the benefits were paid or the injury that necessitated disability payments. Such subrogation rights shall extend only to the recovery of the Fund of benefits it has paid for such hospitalization and treatment, and the Fund shall pay its share of fees and costs associated with such recovery.

Plan Document, § 7.5, Plfs’ Exh. C.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.