District Court, D. Puerto Rico June 23, 1994, Civ. 93-1839 GG (Lopez Del Valle v. Gobierno De La Capital)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-06-1994
OPINION AND ORDER
GIERBOLINI, Senior District Judge.
On June 21, 1993, the plaintiffs, Vilma Lopez del Valle and Juan Mejias Ortiz, filed a tort action against defendants, the Government of the City of San Juan, Monroig Construction Company (hereinafter Monroig), and other unknown parties in the Superior Court of Puerto Rico, San Juan Part, alleging that the defendants’ negligence in the
*35
laying down of tar caused Vilma Lopez del Valle a respiratory illness which has left her permanently disabled. Subsequently, defendant Monroig and its insurer, El Fénix de Puerto Rico (hereinafter El Fénix), filed a third party suit against third party defendants Betterroads Asphalt Corp., Lagoven, S.A. (hereinafter Lagoven), and Chevron, also in the Superior Court of Puerto Rico. Third party defendant Lagoven, S.A. then removed the action to this court. Third party plaintiffs Monroig and El Fénix then moved the court to remand this action back to the Superior Court of Puerto Rico. At a status conference held on March 11, 1994, Monroig and El Fénix withdrew their motion to remand. But now they have filed a motion to dismiss the case against them, docket #17.
We do not understand why Monroig and El Fénix would withdraw their opposition to removal of the whole state action, which included them as parties, only to turn around and file a motion to dismiss which attempts to reach the same end, excluding them from a federal action, and which argues essentially the same points as the motion to remand. We suggest that the parties deliberate more about what actions they take, before they waste the court’s' time. By withdrawing their motion to remand and showing no opposition when we explicitly stated at the status conference that we would exercise jurisdiction over this action, Monroig and El Fénix can be understood as waiving any objection to jurisdiction.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit