Indiana Court of Appeals March 21, 1994, 50A05-9302-CV-44 (Marshall v. Hatfield)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-03-1994
RUCKER, Judge.
This appeal arises out of a landlord-tenant dispute. Landlords John and Marjorie Marshall (collectively "the Marshalls") filed an ejectment action against tenants Anita Hatfield and Jeff Howell (collectively "Hatfield"). The trial court awarded damages to the Mar-shalls in the amount of $100.00. According to the Marshalls, the damage award is inadequate and should have totaled $480.80. We consolidate and rephrase the issues as follows:
1. Were the Marshalls entitled to rental payments after Hatfield vacated the premises pursuant to a court ordered eviction?
2. Did the trial court err in ordering the Marshalls to return a part of Hatfield's security deposit? We affirm.
The record reveals that on April 11, 1992, the Marshalls entered into a written lease agreement with Hatfield. The lease involved a two-bedroom apartment in the Marshalls multi-unit apartment building. A dispute arose the following month when Hatfield began paying rent in partial payments contrary to the terms of the agreement. Further, the Marshalls received complaints that Hatfield's children were noisy and disturbing other tenants in the building.
On May 18, 1992, approximately six weeks after the lease term began, the Marshalls filed an action in small claims court seeking to evict Hatfield and claiming damages for back rent. A possession hearing was held on June 8, 1992, after which the trial court ordered Hatfield to pay the Marshalls all rent then outstanding along with any late fee penalties due. The court also ordered Hatfield to vacate the apartment by June 30, 1992. A damages hearing was then scheduled for July 14, 1992.
At the damages hearing John Marshall testified that Hatfield had complied with the court order in every respect, namely: all rentals and late fees due and owing up to and including the month of June had been paid and Hatfield had vacated the apartment by the end of June.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit