Michigan Court of Appeals November 7, 1994, 144072 (In Re Contempt of Scharg)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-11-1994

207 Mich. App. 438 (1994) 525 N.W.2d 479 In re CONTEMPT OF SCHARG (PEOPLE v. GODFREY) Docket No. 144072. Michigan Court of Appeals. Submitted April 20, 1994, at Detroit. Decided November 7, 1994, at 9:50 A.M. James A. Waske, for Henry M. Scharg. Office of Judicial Assistance, Recorder's Court for the City of Detroit (by Linda D. Ashford, Chief Deputy Judicial Assistant), for the Recorder's Court Judge. *439 Before: WHITE, P.J., and NEFF and M.L. STACEY,[*] JJ. WHITE, P.J. At the conclusion of a criminal trial in which he represented the defendant, attorney Henry M. Scharg was found in contempt pursuant to MCL 600.1711; MSA 27A.1711. Scharg was sentenced to fifteen days in jail and fined $250 pursuant to MCL 600.1715; MSA 27A.1715. He appeals as of right. We vacate the order of adjudication and sentence for contempt and remand for further proceedings. In finding Scharg guilty of contempt, the court cited five incidents that occurred during the course of the trial and in the court's presence, in which the court found Scharg to be disrespectful and disruptive. However, the contempt citation was deferred until the conclusion of the trial. After being informed that the court found his conduct contumacious, Scharg requested a hearing, which was denied. On appeal, Scharg argues that because the contempt order was deferred until the conclusion of the trial, he was entitled to a full hearing before a different judge. We agree. Although summary punishment of contumacious behavior is proper when the behavior is committed in the court's presence, and the court further determines that immediate corrective action is necessary, MCL 600.1711; MSA 27A.1711, summary punishment is regarded with disfavor when deferred until the conclusion of a trial. People v Kurz, 35 Mich App 643, 657; 192 NW2d 594 (1971). The contempt power is limited by necessity and extends only to the least possible power adequate to the end proposed. Id.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.