United States Bankruptcy Court, C.D. Illinois May 17, 1994, 19-80265 (Westpfahl v. Clark (In Re Westpfahl))

Also known as

United States · · · 17-05-1994

OPINION

WILLIAM V. ALTENBERGER, Chief Judge.

Before the Court are a number of cases which involve the right of a Chapter 12 Debt- or to make direct payments to priority and secured creditors without recompense to the Chapter 12 Standing Trustee. In two of those cases,

Thomas Lee Ferguson & Catherine Ann Ferguson,

(FERGUSONS), Case No. 92-91658, and

John Robert Westpfahl & Patricia Ellen Westpfahl,

(WESTPFAHLS), Case No. 92-82691, the Debtors brought adversary proceedings against Michael D. Clark, the Standing Chapter 12 Trustee (Standing Trustee) and the United States of America, acting through Kenneth C. Meeker, the United States Trustee for this region (U.S. Trustee), which are identical, each containing seven counts.

1

In Count 1, the

*340

WESTPFAHLS and the FERGUSONS seek a determination from this Court that a Chapter 12 debtor can make direct payments to creditors without the imposition of a trustee’s fee. The second count, closely related to the first, requests a finding that a claim which is consensually modified prior to confirmation is not “impaired.” Constitutional issues are raised by Counts 3 and 4. The WESTPFAHLS and the FERGUSONS assert that the Office of the United States Trustee and the Standing Trustee’s fee are unconstitutional under the Uniformity Clause. Under Count 5 it is alleged that the Chapter 12 Trustee “potentially” may receive excessive compensation. Count 6 involves the method of computing the Standing Trustee’s fee. The subject of the final count is the standing order of the Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of Illinois, requiring a Chapter 12 Debtor to deposit $500.00 cash with the Standing Trustee within fifteen days of the filing of the bankruptcy petition. In both adversary proceedings, the United States Trustee filed a motion to dismiss which was joined in by the Standing Trustee.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.