United States Bankruptcy Court, N.D. Georgia June 6, 1994, 19-51725 (Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Co. v. Homer (In Re Homer))
Also known as
United States · · · 06-06-1994
*793
DECISION AND ORDER DETERMINING DISCHARGEABILITY OF INDEBTEDNESS
JAMES E. MASSEY, Bankruptcy Judge.
In these cases challenging the discharge-ability of claims on grounds of fraud, the Debtor contends that the issue is simply one of responsibility. He denies having read documents, including a residential loan application, that bear his signature. He denies having known that the loan broker submitted the residential loan application to a lender to obtain a loan. Instead, he testified that he believed the application was to be used merely to find out whether he “qualified” for a loan. He denies having had knowledge of an encumbrance against the property securing the loan at the time he received the loan proceeds. In short, the Debtor denies all responsibility for his actions concerning the loan, except ordinary liability on the note. Even if he is responsible for having made deceitful misstatements, the Debtor contends that the Plaintiffs failed to rely, or were irresponsible in relying, on those misstatements.
The creditors contend that this case is about integrity. They accuse the Debtor of knowingly and fraudulently misleading them about his financial and personal situations.
*794
They contend that they reasonably relied to their detriment on incorrect information that he provided to them.
Thus, to adjudicate this dispute, the court must decide who bears what responsibility for actions taken or omitted by the parties and who is telling the truth. The court has carefully considered the evidence presented at the five-day trial and concludes that the Debtor must bear responsibility for his reckless failure to read the loan application. First Union Mortgage Corporation reasonably relied on misrepresentations concerning his residence and marital status but did not reasonably rely on misstatements regarding his financial condition. In addition, the Debtor intentionally breached a duty to inform the Plaintiffs that there was a lien on the property securing the loan.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit