California Court of Appeal November 30, 1994, B083598 (Southern California Rapid Transit District v. Superior Court)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-11-1994

Opinion

CROSKEY, J.

Petitioners Southern California Rapid Transit District (District), Ernesto Fuentes (Fuentes) and Nick Patsaouras (Patsaouras) (collectively, defendants)

1

seek a writ of mandate from this court compelling the trial court to grant their summary judgment motion on the complaint of the real parties in interest, Allen Laster (Laster) and Richard Yeats (Yeats) (collectively, plaintiffs).

This action arose out of the claim by plaintiffs that they were wrongfully terminated by the District from their position as employees hired by the District to investigate fraud, waste and corruption. They alleged that their terminations were in retaliation for reports made by them of suspected forgery, fraud, mismanagement and an official cover-up of such acts in connection with the certification of a minority contractor.

Defendants filed a motion for summary judgment and summary adjudication of issues as to all seven counts filed by Laster and Yeats. Although the trial court agreed with defendants on all but two of the causes of action filed by plaintiffs, it denied summary relief with respect to their second cause of action (wrongful termination in retaliation for reporting illegal conduct) and their fourth cause of action (wrongful termination in violation of First Amendment free speech rights).

*718

We conclude that issues of fact do exist with respect to plaintiffs’ claims of (1) retaliatory termination in violation of a fundamental statutory public policy and (2) infringement of their First Amendment right of free speech in violation of the Civil Rights Act (42 U.S.C. § 1983). We also reject defendants’ qualified immunity claims under both state and federal law. We therefore deny the requested writ relief.

Factual and Procedural Background

The District was, at the times relevant to this matter, a governmental agency created by statute to plan and operate mass transit in Los Angeles County. (Pub. Utilities Code, § 30001 et seq.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.