Court of Appeals of Texas February 17, 1994, B14-92-01022-CR (Pine v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-02-1994

*26

OPINION

LEE, Justice.

This is an appeal from a felony conviction for driving while intoxicated. Punishment was assessed at three years probation and a $500.00 fíne. We reverse and order entry of an acquittal.

Appellant was charged with driving while intoxicated. Because the indictment alleged that appellant had been convicted twice previously for the same type offense, this charge was enhanced to a felony. Appellant pled not guilty to the court and orally waived his right to a jury trial. Appellant and the State then entered into a written stipulation of evidence using a form normally used for taking guilty pleas. Through interlineation, appellant and the prosecutor modified the form by inserting the word “not” before the words “true” and “guilty” each time they appeared in the form. Appellant also made a handwritten notation on the form. The notation stated that, “Defendant agrees that the State offers this stipulation and he does not object to its admission. He pleads not guilty to the offense of DWI.” This notation was then signed by appellant, and the modified form was then signed by defense counsel, the State’s attorney and the trial court. In this stipulation, which tracked the language of the indictment, appellant agreed to waive the appearance, confrontation, and cross-examination of witnesses and further agreed that the State

could

offer evidence by affidavits, written statements of witnesses, and other documentary evidence. After executing the stipulation of evidence form, the State offered it into evidence and then rested. The defense offered no evidence. The trial court then accepted the stipulation and based on that stipulation, found appellant guilty as charged. In a single point of error, appellant contends that the evidence is insufficient to support the trial court’s finding of guilt because the stipulation did not constitute evidence and the State failed to offer any other evidence to prove appellant’s guilt.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.