Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania April 11, 1994 (West v. Western Center, Department of Public Welfare)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-1994
FRIEDMAN, Judge.
Betty J. West (Employee) appeals from an order of the State Civil Service Commission (Commission) denying her Petition for Award of Attorney’s Fees and Costs and Expenses (Costs Petition) pursuant to Section 2033 of the Costs Act.1
On August 17, 1992, this Court issued an opinion in favor of Employee, reinstating a promotion she had received from Western Center (Employer), a facility of the Department of Public Welfare, that Employer subsequently retracted by “involuntary demotion.”*422 West v. Department of Public Welfare, 150 Pa.Coinmonwealth Ct. 59, 614 A.2d 357 (1992). In West, we held that the “involuntary demotion” was invalid under Section 706 of the Civil Service Act3 because Employee’s job performance had been exemplary.
Employer’s position was that its action did not constitute an involuntary demotion under Section 706, but was a proper retraction of an invalid promotion under Section 95.7(d)(8) of the Commission’s rules4 and Pennsylvania Department of Education v. White, 60 Pa.Commonwealth Ct. 599, 432 A.2d 291 (1981). The basis in fact for Employer’s position was the content of a letter dated November 23, 1990, informing Employee of her “involuntary demotion.”5
Employer subsequently filed a Petition for Allowance of Appeal to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which was denied. Employee thereafter filed a Costs Petition which the Commission denied, concluding that Employer’s position was substantially justified because: (1) Employer returned Employee to her original position after it was determined that she had been improperly promoted, and (2) the demotion was done in accordance with the law as Employer understood it.6
On appeal,7 Employee contends that the Commission erred as a matter of law in concluding that the position taken by Employer in demoting Employee was “substantially justified” as defined by the Costs Act.
The purpose of the Costs Act is twofold.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit