Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma December 20, 1994, No. 83655 (Big V Feeds, Inc. v. Boyd)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-1994

MEMORANDUM OPINION

CARL B. JONES, Judge:

Larry Boyd was an employee of Big V Feeds for a number of years in the position of a salesman. In that capacity he was afforded a company vehicle. He was offered, and accepted, the responsibility of the manager’s position at a new retail outlet in McAl-ester, Oklahoma. Mr. Boyd resided in Muskogee and thus was required to commute daily to the store. He and his family owned one automobile, and to accommodate him the employer allowed him to retain his company vehicle until he completed his move to McAl-ester. One morning, intending to pick up some grass seed for the store on the way, Mr. Boyd was proceeding to work and was involved in a traffic accident which proved fatal. His wife, Donna L. Boyd, sought and was granted Workers’ Compensation surviv- or’s benefits. The Petitioner, Big V Feeds, now seeks review of that award.

Petitioner offers three arguments to demonstrate the erroneous nature of the judgment here reviewed. It is contended the death of the decedent was the result of his willful failure to use mandated safety equipment and that the death did not arise out of the course of employment. Lastly, it is argued the accident and the death was caused by an idiopathic disease unrelated to employment.

This court rejects the contention, unsupported by authority save a bankruptcy definition of the term willful, that decedent’s *1278speeding or failure to use seat belts could be classified as a willful failure to use a guard or safety equipment as that concept is defined in the Compensation act, as would render the accident not covered under the act as provided in 85 O.S.1991 § 11. As the record before this court stands, there is evidence a seat belt was not worn and his headlights were not observed. A willful failure in this regard carries an idea of premeditation, obstinacy and intentional wrongdoing. Wise-Buchanan Coal Co. v. Ray, 157 Okla. 197, 17 P.2d 360 (1932); Gregory v. Oklahoma Operating Co., 139 Okla. 243, 282 P.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.