Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit July 12, 1994, 93-3634 (Eastern Electric Apparatus Repair Co., Inc. v. Jefferson Smurfit Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-07-1994
CUMMINGS, Circuit Judge.
In late April 1991, a turbine generator used by Jefferson Smurfit Corp. (“Smurfit”) at its container board plant in Alton, Illinois, was severely damaged. In early May 1991, Eastern Electric Apparatus Repair Company, Inc. (“Eastern Electric”) agreed to repair the damaged turbine for $288,500. Eastern Electric agreed to begin work on May 10, 1991, and to have the generator ready for use by June 25, 1991.
In order to encourage timely completion— Smurfit knew that it would be subject to a $160,000 charge from its local utility company if the generator was not back in service by July 1,1991 — Smurfit agreed to pay Eastern Electric a bonus if the repair work was completed prior to June 25, 1991.
1
For its part, Eastern Electric agreed that if it failed to complete the repairs by June 25, it would pay Smurfit, “as liquidated damages,” $2,000 for each day after June 25 that the repair work remained unfinished — up to a maximum of $10,000 — plus an additional $40,000 if the repair work was not completed by July 1, the day Smurfit would incur the $160,000 utility charge. The addendum to the contract setting out the bonus and liquidated damages provided that “[njotwithstanding the above [bonus/liquidated damages agreement], Smurfit shall have all rights and remedies provided elsewhere in th[e] [contract].”
Finally, Eastern Electric expressly warranted that “[a]ll the material and workmanship” it would provide would be “merchantable and fit for the purpose intended and [ ] fulfil and conform to the specifications required by th[e] Project_” Eastern Electric further agreed that its “warranties [would] extend to all consequential damages suffered by [Smurfit] by reason of [Eastern Electric’s] breach thereof.”
Eastern Electric did not complete the repair of the turbine generator until November 25,1991, five months after the agreed date of completion. As a result of this delay, Smur-fit suffered substantial losses.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit