Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit November 9, 1994, 93-3577 (Dale M. Winningham v. North American Resources Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-11-1994

42 F.3d 981 Dale M. WINNINGHAM, Plaintiff and Supplemental Plaintiff-Appellant (93-3577), Plaintiff-Appellee (93-3578), v. NORTH AMERICAN RESOURCES CORPORATION, Defendant-Appellant (93-3578), Insurance Company of North America; Neare, Gibbs & Company, Supplemental Defendants-Appellees (93-3577). Nos. 93-3577, 93-3578. United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit. Argued Aug. 4, 1994. Decided Nov. 9, 1994. Paul B. Martins (argued), James B. Helmer, Jr. (briefed), Helmer, Lugbill, Martins & Neff, Cincinnati, OH, Meredith Lynn Lawrence (briefed), Lawrence & Schletker, Covington, KY, for Dale M. Winningham. James J. Montgomery (argued and briefed), Montgomery, Rennie & Jonson, Frederick M. Morgan, Jr., Cincinnati, OH, for Insurance Co. of North America, Neare, Gibbs & Co. Richard D. Lameier (argued and briefed), Arthur H. Schlemmer (argued), Rosemary E. Scollard, Barron, Peck & Bennie, Cincinnati, OH, for North American Resources Corp. Before: GUY and BOGGS, Circuit Judges; and CLELAND, District Judge.* RALPH B. GUY, Jr., Circuit Judge. 1 These consolidated appeals stem from a personal injury action filed by Dale M. Winningham against the vendor and purchaser of the land on which his injuries occurred. After a lengthy trial, the jury found that the defendants had acted negligently, and damages were awarded in favor of Winningham. One of the defendants, North American Resources Corporation (NARC), contends on appeal that it cannot be liable to Winningham because the accident causing his injuries actually occurred on public land, not its property, and thus it owed no duty to him. NARC also argues in the alternative that it satisfied any duty it might have owed to Winningham, since Winningham's employer knew of the dangerous conditions that led to the accident. NARC further maintains that the district court's award of prejudgment interest in favor of Winningham was an abuse of the court's discretion.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.