Fairfax County Circuit Court August 22, 1994, Case No. (Criminal) 85565 (Commonwealth v. Lemos)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-08-1994

By Judge Thomas A. Fortkort

This case came before the Court on Defendant Pan Jon Lemos’ Motion for Appointment of an Eyewitness Identification Expert. The expert would be expected to testify at Lemos’ trial on the unreliability of eyewitness identification testimony. Lemos is indigent and is currently represented by the Fairfax Office of the Public Defender. Each of the proposed expert witnesses is academically qualified to render an opinion. The cost for their services is within the normal amounts charged in this area for similarly qualified experts; The sole question is whether the appointment of any of these experts would be “appropriate.” Singleton v. Commonwealth, 16 Va. App. 841, 842 (1993). The Singleton decision draws from Code of Virginia § 19.2-163(2), which authorizes the circuit court to “direct the payment of such reasonable expenses incurred [by court-appointed counsel] ... as it deems appropriate under the circumstances of the case.”

The Court assumes that the term “appropriate” must be defined against the Constitutional requirements of Ake v. Oklahoma, 470 U.S. 68 (1985). In Ake, the United States Supreme Court held that access to a psychiatric expert was a fundamental right of an indigent defendant under both the Sixth Amendment right to counsel and the Fourteenth Amendment which applies the Sixth Amendment strictures to the States. Ake, 470 U.S. at 76. Further, the court held, “the state is required to provide an indigent de*313fendant with the raw materials integral to the building of an effective defense.” Id. at 77.

In this Court’s opinion, the case at bar does not stand on Constitutional principles. This Court finds that the Ake reasoning does not apply, as in this case, to experts whose testimony may be merely helpful, but not crucial, to the defendant.1 Instead, this case must be decided on general principles of law which govern admissibility of the testimony of an eyewitness identification expert.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.