District Court, C.D. Illinois December 30, 1994, No. 93-3158 (Balbinot v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1994

*547

OPINION

BICHAED MILLS, District Judge:

FACTS: Balbinot’s former commanding officer allegedly made false and derogatory comments about him to fellow service members.

CLAIM: Violation of the Privacy Act of 1974.

DEFENSE: The parties agree the alleged statements were untrue and were not contained in any government document, therefore, no violation of the Act occurred.

RESULT: Summary Judgment for the government.

7. Background

Balbinot was enlisted in the United States Navy from 1976 to November 1991. From 1980 through 1991 Plaintiff served as a recruiter for the Navy. For at least the last four years of his naval career he was assigned to the Naval Reserve Recruiting Command, Detachment Two, Naval Training Center, Great Lakes, Illinois.

In late summer or early fall of 1990, Chief Petty Officer Balbinot’s Officer-in-Charge, Captain Rex Settlemoir1 became aware of the possibility that CPO Balbinot had misused government vehicles. CAPT Settlemoir ordered an investigation which resulted in findings that Plaintiff had indeed misused government vehicles. During the course of the investigation it was also discovered that Plaintiff may have submitted false travel forms, misused government telephones and possibly been involved in improper enlistments. Working with CAPT Settlemoir’s office, the Navy Legal Services Office at Great Lakes determined that some of CPO Balbi-not’s conduct violated the Uniform Code of Military Justice.

Sometime after the investigation began— but before it concluded — CPO Balbinot was admitted to the Psychiatric ward at the Great Lakes Naval Training Center suffering from chronic depression. He remained hospitalized for approximately seven months.

After CAPT Settlemoir’s investigation was complete, a decision was made to proceed to a court-martial. CAPT Settlemoir did not have the authority to convene a court-martial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.