District Court, D. New Hampshire February 21, 1995, CV-94-458-L (Chartier v. Shalala, Secretary)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-1995

Chartier v . Shalala, Secretary CV-94-458-L 02/21/95

THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE

DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

Mark Chartier

v. #C-94-458-L

Donna L . Shalala,

Secretary of Health

and Human Services

ORDER

Plaintiff Mark Chartier seeks review, pursuant to 42 U.S.C.

§405(g), of a final determination of the Secretary of Health and

Human Services (HHS) denying his application for Social Security

benefits. Currently before the court are Plaintiff's Motion for

Order Reversing Decision of the Secretary (Doc. 5 ) and

Defendant's Motion for Order Affirming the Decision of the

Secretary (Doc. 6 ) . For the reasons set forth below, the

plaintiff's motion is denied and the defendant's motion is

granted.

BACKGROUND

Plaintiff, Mark Chartier, is a 34 year-old, high school

graduate, whose past relevant work experience involves truck

driving, installing commercial air conditioning and heating and

operating machines. T r . 4 7 , 359-360.

Plaintiff last worked on October 3 1 , 1989. On this day he

fell from a ladder injuring both knees. T r . 48-49. Previous to

this injury, plaintiff had suffered a back injury. Tr. 49. The

initial injury from the October 31st fall was to the left knee

and the plaintiff received medical treatment for the injury. Tr.

148. Persistent pain and increased swelling forced the plaintiff

to consult D r . James M . Shea, an orthopaedic surgeon, on November

1 0 , 1989. T r . 1 6 0 , 167. At that time, D r . Shea's diagnosis was

internal derangement of the left knee. T r . 151. The plaintiff

was admitted for arthroscopic surgery to the knee on November 1 5 ,

1989. T r . 152.

Plaintiff continued to receive treatment from D r . Shea and

mild progress was noted with the left knee over the course of the

following month. T r . 161. As early as five days following

surgery, however, an increasing problem arose in the right knee.

Tr. 161. By January 1 1 , 1990, both knees were exhibiting

increased problems and pain. T r . 162.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.