Oregon Supreme Court August 3, 1995, CC 9011-07573; CA A74864; SC S41463 (Eagle Industries, Inc. v. Thompson)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-08-1995

*400

FADELEY, J.

This case turns on the meaning of a provision in a contract among three parties entered into in July of 1990. The contract settled a previous court case between the Tuckers and Toyoda, after trial and verdict, but before judgment. Thompson had been the Tuckers’ lawyer in that earlier court case. He obtained the verdict in their favor. At their request, he negotiated the settlement agreement after verdict. However, even before trial and verdict, a dispute arose between Thompson and the Tuckers over Thompson’s fees. That dispute continues today, and is the basis for the present breach of contract action brought by the Tuckers against Thompson.

Although this case is separate from the one in which the verdict was entered, where Thompson represented the Tuckers against Toyoda, background facts from that case are necessary to an understanding of the present breach of contract claim. In the previous case, Toyoda as plaintiff claimed a $340,000 balance due by the Tuckers on the purchase price of a construction machine from Toyoda and sought a court order returning the machine to Toyoda.

1

The Tuckers hired Thompson to defend them in that action and eventually to bring counterclaims for fraud and for damages for losses suffered because the machine did not perform as represented. The initial fee agreement between lawyer and client was based on a stated hourly rate of charge for the lawyer’s time and that of his assistants. That hourly rate was changed and, thereafter, in January of the year of the Toyoda case trial, a written fee agreement was signed. That agreement provided that Thompson would receive a percentage of any punitive damages awarded, in addition to hourly fees. In April, atrial to a jury was completed. Although the jury awarded Toyoda a substantial sum as the unpaid portion of the machine’s purchase price, it also awarded the Tuckers on their counterclaims $179,832 in special damages and $1.5 million in punitive damages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.