Michigan Court of Appeals June 20, 1995, Docket 165565 (Brown v. Swartz Creek Memorial Post 3720—veterans of Foreign Wars, Inc)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-06-1995

Per Curiam.

Defendant Swartz Creek Memorial Post 3720 — Veterans of Foreign Wars, Inc., appeals as of right from a June 15, 1992, judgment of $40,000 for plaintiff following a jury trial. The judgment was entered against the vfw and the

*18

individual defendant, Johnny Ward, jointly and severally. We vacate the judgment and remand for entry of an amended judgment in accordance with this opinion.

This case arose as the result of an altercation between plaintiff and Ward. Ward had consumed alcohol at the vfw, then went to the home of his estranged wife, and confronted plaintiff. Ward believed that plaintiff was having sexual relations with Ward’s wife. A fight ensued, during which plaintiff was beaten and stabbed. Ward pleaded guilty of felonious assault in criminal proceedings.

Plaintiff filed a civil suit against Ward under the theories of assault and battery and negligence. Plaintiff also brought a claim against the vfw for violating the dramshop act, MCL 436.22

et seq.;

MSA 18.993

et seq.

The case was assigned to Genesee Circuit Judge Robert Ransom. However, trial began before Judge Nathaniel Perry, a visiting judge sitting for Judge Ransom. After three days of testimony, the matter was adjourned for thirty-four days because of scheduling difficulties. The trial resumed with Judge Ransom presiding. The vfw moved for a mistrial based on the delay; the motion was denied.

At the conclusion of the trial, the jury entered its verdict via a special verdict form that contained fourteen questions with answer blanks. The answers to the first two questions were supplied by the trial judge, i.e., in answer to the first question, the court took judicial notice that Ward had committed an assault and battery upon plaintiff based on Ward’s criminal conviction and, in answer to the second question, it took notice that Ward’s assault and battery was a proximate cause of plaintiff’s injury.

The next two questions concerned plaintiff’s claim against the vfw.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.