Court of Appeals of South Carolina January 30, 1995, 2297 (State v. Philpot)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-01-1995

Shaw, Judge:

James Philpot was convicted of manufacture of marijuana and possession of marijuana. He appeals his conviction based

*460

upon (1) the trial court’s refusal of his motion to suppress the evidence gathered in the search of his home, and (2) the court’s refusal to require the prosecution to turn over to the defense a written statement of a confidential informant. We reverse.

On March 29, 1993, Officer Garry Bryant of the Pickens County Sheriffs Department signed an affidavit to obtain a search warrant for marijuana and marijuana paraphernalia at the residence of the appellant. The affidavit contained the following statement:

Within the past 72 hours, a confidential informant has seen a quantity of marijuana in the residence to be searched. Also in the past, agents with the Special Operations Div. of the Pickens County Sheriffs Office have received information the [sic] one of the persons who lives at the residence, Jim Philpot, is involved in illicit drug activity.

The magistrate issued the search warrant. Officers of the sheriffs department executed the search warrant and seized evidence of marijuana seeds, two marijuana plants, a partially smoked marijuana cigarette and a set of scales.

Prior to trial, Philpot’s counsel moved to suppress the evidence seized during the search because the name of the confidential informant had not been disclosed and the affidavit for the search warrant was devoid of information as to the informant’s reliability. The court denied the motion. During cross-examination, defense counsel asked Officer Bryant whether he told the magistrate “why this informant was supposedly dependable and reliable.” Officer Bryant replied, “I presented him with a statement from the informant.” Defense counsel moved for the production of the statement pursuant to his Brady motion. The court examined the statement and ruled there was nothing in it which would assist the defense and denied the motion to produce.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.