District Court, S.D. New York March 26, 1995, 93 Civ. 3108 (LAP) (Robinson v. Random House, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-03-1995

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

PRESKA, District Judge.

Plaintiff, Jack E. Robinson (“Robinson”), has brought this action seeking a declaration that his book, entitled

American Icarus: The Majestic Rise and Tragic Fall of Pan Am

(the “Robinson Book”), does not infringe on the copyright and license rights held by defendants (collectively “Daley”) in another book, entitled

American Saga: Juan Trippe and His Pan Am Empire

(the “Daley Book”). Both parties have moved for summary judgment and Daley has moved for a preliminary injunction. Finding that the undisputed facts demonstrate that the Robinson Book infringes on the Daley Book to an extraordinary degree, Daley’s motion for summary judgment is granted, and a permanent injunction shall issue prohibiting further distribution of the Robinson Book.

BACKGROUND

On February 21, 1980, Random House, Inc. (“Random House”) published the Daley Book, a biography of Juan Trippe, the founder of Pan Am Airlines. The copyright in this book, which was duly registered with the U.S. Copyright Office as Registration No. TX 489-231, was effective as of May 29, 1980; the copyright currently is held by Riviera Productions, Ltd. Random House holds licensed distribution rights in the book.

On October 8, 1992, Robinson entered into a contract with McGraw-Hill, Inc. (“McGraw-Hill”) for the publication of his manuscript which concerned the growth and eventual decline of Pan Am. On March 29, 1993, however, McGraw-Hill cancelled its contract with Robinson on the ground that it believed that the Robinson Book infringed upon the copyright held in the Daley Book. Robinson responded to the cancellation by filing an action on April 5, 1993 against McGraw-Hill to enforce his publishing contract. Robinson voluntarily dismissed that action,

Robinson v. McGraw-Hill,

93 Civ. 2162 (LAP), on April 16, 1993. Robinson thereafter sought permission from Daley and Random House to use certain portions of the Daley Book in his own treatment of Pan Am.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.