District Court, S.D. New York June 27, 1995, 94 Civ. 7710 (RWS), 95 Civ. 3315 (RWS) (In Re the Complaint of American President Lines, Ltd.)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-06-1995
OPINION
SWEET, District Judge.
Motions are before this Court relating to
forum non conveniens,
transfer of venue and choice of law in two related limitation proceedings arising out of the collision of two vessels in Korean waters.
For the reasons set forth below, in the limitation proceeding (the “APL Action”) brought by American President Lines, Ltd. (“APL”), APL’s motion to strike the Fifth affirmative defenses of Hanjin Shipping Company Ltd. (“Hanjin”) and Highlight Navigation Corporation (“Highlight”) (together the “Hanjin Claimants”) regarding Korean law will be granted and that defense will be stricken with leave to replead. APL’s motion for summary judgment as to the Hanjin Claimants’ Sixth and Seventh affirmative defenses the APL Action will be granted.
In a related limitation action brought by Hanjin (the “Hanjin Action”), Hanjin’s motion to dismiss that action on
forum non conveniens
grounds will be denied.
In the APL Action, APL and numerous cargo claimants move to strike affirmative defenses raised by Hanjin and Highlight in their Answer, these defenses being the Han-jin Claimants’ Fifth, Sixth and Seventh affirmative defenses, respectively asserting that: (i) Korean law governs all claims in the APL action (Fifth); (ii) the APL action should be dismissed on grounds of
forum non conve-niens
(Sixth); and (iii) venue should be transferred to the Western District of Washington (Seventh). At an initial hearing this Court determined to treat this motion as one for summary judgment regarding the
forum non conveniens
and venue transfer defenses, since these defenses turned on questions of fact, and the motion was so deemed. The parties were granted an opportunity and additional time to supplement their submissions, further argument was heard, and the motion is now considered as one for summary judgment as to the affirmative defenses.
In the Hanjin Action, which was commenced by Hanjin and Highlight in the U.S.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit