Superior Court of Pennsylvania January 31, 1995 (Allen v. Kaplan)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-01-1995

HIJDOCK, Judge:

This is an appeal from the order granting Appellees a new trial on the basis of negligence and informed consent. This matter was before us previously on appeal from an order disposing of post-trial motions. We remanded to the trial court for a complete disposition of post-trial motions which were only partially ruled upon prior to the earlier appeal, 433 Pa.Super. 647, 639 A.2d 835. The trial court has subsequently granted the new trial and denied Appellant’s exceptions. We affirm.

This action for negligence and lack of informed consent was brought by Appellees following treatment provided to Mrs.

*265

Allen for bunions. Initial surgery was performed by Appellant, and two subsequent surgeries were performed by other physicians. Mrs. Allen alleged that the surgery performed by Appellant was done negligently, and Appellant failed to obtain informed consent before performing the surgery. A jury trial was held and, at the conclusion, the jury returned a verdict in favor of Appellant, finding no negligence. The trial court then entered the verdict. Appellees filed post-trial motions which were granted, giving rise to the order for a new trial. The court then stated that its order would become final unless exceptions were filed within twenty days. Appellant filed exceptions, and, following a hearing on the exceptions, the court entered the order granting Appellees a new trial.

Appellant raises the following issues in his appeal:

1. Does a plaintiff preserve his objection that an expert’s report constitutes inadmissible hearsay when the plaintiffs counsel makes a specific objection on another ground never mentioning hearsay?

2. Should a new trial be granted when an expert reads into evidence the report of a non-testifying expert upon which the testifying expert relied in reaching his opinion?

3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.