Court of Appeals of Minnesota September 5, 1995, C6-95-654 (LaMusga v. Commissioner of Public Safety)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-09-1995

OPINION

HUSPENI, Judge.

The Commissioner of Public Safety denied and cancelled appellant Anthony Eli Lamusga’s driver’s license after receiving a report that he had violated the license condition of total abstinence from alcohol. The trial court denied Lamusga’s petition for reinstatement and he appeals. Because we conclude that the denial and cancellation of Lamusga’s license did not violate procedural or substantive due process, or exceed statutory authority, we affirm.

FACTS

After appellant was involved in four alcohol-related driving incidents from 1976 to 1986, the Commissioner of Public Safety (Commissioner) cancelled and denied his driver’s license as “inimical to public safety” in October 1986. After appellant met rehabilitation requirements in December 1988, his driver’s license was reinstated on the condition that he totally abstain from alcohol and controlled substances. He signed a statement acknowledging he understood his driver’s license would be again cancelled and denied

if the Commissioner has sufficient cause to believe that [he had] consumed alcohol or a controlled substance, regardless if a motor vehicle was involved * * *.

Appellant’s driver’s license also indicated it was valid only when accompanied by a “B card,” which stated “any use of alcohol or drugs invalidates license.”

*646

After midnight on May 22, 1993, an officer stopped appellant, who was walking in the street, and observed that he appeared to be very intoxicated. The officer gave appellant a preliminary breath test, which registered a “fail” reading. He submitted a report of his observations to the Commissioner. The Commissioner received the report on May 28,1993, and cancelled and denied appellant’s driving privileges effective June 7, 1993, based upon sufficient cause to believe appellant had violated the abstinence restriction.

On August 15, 1994, appellant petitioned for reinstatement of his driver’s license. He now appeals the trial court’s denial of reinstatement.

ISSUES

1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.