Missouri Court of Appeals March 30, 1995, No. 19460 (Farm Bureau Town & Country Insurance Co. of Missouri v. Threlkeld)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1995

CHARLES B. BLACKMAR, Senior Judge.

Appellants Morgan County Feeders, Inc., and Agri-Tech, Inc. filed suit against Appellants Robert and Patsy Threlkeld and others in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, seeking damages for the alleged conversion by the Threl-kelds of several hundred cattle at locations in Indiana and Michigan. The Threlkelds tendered defense of the action to the Respondent, Farm Bureau Town and Country Insurance Company of Missouri, which offered to defend the suit with reservation of rights but disclaimed coverage. This offer was refused and Farm Bureau filed suit in the court below against the several Appellants seeking a declaratory judgment that it was not obliged to defend the Indiana federal suit. The trial judge found that there was no coverage, accompanying his ruling with a helpful and well-considered opinion, supplemented following request for reconsideration. We believe that he correctly ruled the case and affirm.

The Threlkelds were in the business of farming and raising cattle in Howell and Oregon Counties in Missouri. Commencing in 1988, they entered into a contract with one Herman Miller, who was to place calves on farms in Indiana for feeding until they *668reached a specified weight. Most of the cattle were purchased in Indiana and Michigan by Steve Western, the Threlkelds’ agent, but, at the beginning of the operation, Robert Threlkeld took 100 to 250 calves from Missouri to Indiana and these also were placed by Miller. During the entire operation Western and Miller placed approximately 2,650 calves for the Threlkeld operation. When the calves placed by Miller reached the desired size, 95 percent of them were transferred to a sale barn in Topeka, Indiana, rented by the Threlkelds, where the Threl-kelds reacquired ownership of the calves. While the operation was ongoing, Western took 14 bulls and 12 Holstein cows to the Threlkelds’ home in Missouri.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.