Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 2, 1995 (Schweitzer v. Heppner)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-02-1995

Cardona, P. J.

Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Bradley, J.), entered January 7, 1994 in Ulster County, *836upon a decision of the court in favor of defendants Hubertus F. Heppner and Maria Heppner.

In 1949, Herbert Shultis and Nellie Shultis, the owners of a large parcel of rural land, conveyed a small lot to plaintiff. Herbert Shultis, who was not a surveyor, laid out and measured the lot. Plaintiff’s rear and easterly boundary line is described as follows: "running thence in a northerly direction 144 feet more or less, in a straight line to a cherry tree” (emphasis supplied).

In 1962, Herbert Shultis, with the assistance of Herbert Shultis, Jr. (hereinafter Shultis), whose name had been added to the deed, laid out and measured a lot to the rear and east of plaintiff’s lot. This new lot, now owned by defendants Hubertus F. Heppner and Maria Heppner (hereinafter collectively referred to as defendants), contains the following description: "and running thence in a westerly direction and at right angles to said New Town Road 100 feet to the easterly bounds of [plaintiff]; thence northerly along the easterly bounds of [plaintiff] 103 feet more or less to a stake driven in the ground” (emphasis supplied).

During the 1980s a dispute arose over the location of the parties’ rear lines with plaintiff contending that he had adversely possessed a strip of land beyond his rear boundary. Plaintiff commenced this action in 1987. Thereafter in 1989, deciding that ambiguities in defendants’ deed permitted the conclusion that the parcels were not contiguous and that certain parol evidence supported a contention that defendants’ rear or westerly line was not straight but concave, plaintiff procured a quitclaim deed for a small parcel allegedly being the land between the two parcels. The description of the new parcel included a portion running underneath defendants’ home.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.