Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 9, 1995 (New York Overnight Partners, L. P. v. Gordon)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-11-1995

OPINION OF THE COURT

Tom, J.

The issue raised in this appeal is whether the term "land”, as utilized in a certain Ground Lease Agreement, includes the hotel and improvements situated on the site, for the purpose of setting rent for the renewal lease terms.

The Ground Lease Agreement in question (the Lease) was executed on or about December 30, 1963 between Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company, as lessor, and Louis Berry and F.B.M. Manufacturing Company, as lessees, and concerned the premises designated as 112 Central Park South, New York, New York. The building located on the site was known at that time as the Navarro Hotel and is currently known as the Ritz-Carlton Hotel. Plaintiff and counterclaim defendant-appellant New York Overnight Partners, L. P. is the successor-in-interest to the original lessee and defendants and counterclaimants-respondents Joan Gordon, Alice S. Kandell and Donald Trump are the successors-in-interest to the original lessor.

The Lease provides for an initial term of 30 years with an annual rental rate of $78,000. Article VI of the Lease further provides that the lessee shall have the right to extend the Lease term for four successive 15-year periods at a rental based upon "the appraised value of the land [at the time of each renewal] but to be not less than Seventy Eight Thousand ($78,000) Dollars annually”.

Plaintiff asserts in its complaint that in October 1993, or three months prior to the expiration of the Lease, representatives of the parties to the Agreement commenced negotiations in an attempt to agree on the "appraised value” of the land *23and to set an appropriate rental amount for the first renewal term. It was, and is, plaintiffs position that the term "land” as used in the Lease refers to the vacant parcel of land, exclusive of the hotel and all other improvements, and subject to current governmental restrictions, including zoning regulations, as well as restrictions set forth in the Lease.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.