New York Supreme Court April 20, 1995 (Stern v. Delphi Internet Services Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-04-1995

*22OPINION OF THE COURT

Emily Jane Goodman, J.

BACKGROUND AND FACTS

This case involves state-of-the-art electronic communication and public figures.

Howard Stern (Stern), a controversial radio talk show celebrity and heavily promoted public figure, announced his candidacy for the office of Governor of the State of New York in the spring of 1994. Defendant Delphi Internet Services Corporation (Delphi) provides access to paid subscribers to the vast electronic "information super highway”, known as the Internet. Stern brought this lawsuit because his photograph was used without his permission in an advertisement for the online bulletin board service Delphi had set up to debate Stern’s own political candidacy. There is no allegation that the defendant obtained the outlandish, bare buttock photo unlawfully or improperly. It is clear that plaintiff posed for the picture, but he does not object on grounds of its lewdness.

Delphi, as an on-line computer network, offers three types of information services to its subscribers: (1) "hard information”, such as news stories, stock quotes, or reference material; (2) computer games; (3) user interaction, meaning electronic mail, on-line conferences or bulletin board messages. Delphi has been operating for 11 years and currently has over 100,000 subscribers who pay "on-line time” for access.

Delphi set up on its on-line electronic bulletin board a subscriber participation debate on the merits of Stern’s candidacy. A June 1994 full page advertisement in New York Magazine and the New York Post featured the flamboyant photograph of Stern in leather pants which largely exposed his buttocks. The ad caption read "Should this man be the next governor of New York?” and continued: "You’ve heard him. You’ve seen him. You’ve been exposed to his Private Parts. Now he’s stumping to be governor. Maybe it’s time to tell the world exactly what you think. The Internet’s the one frontier even the King of (Almost) All Media hasn’t conquered.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.