New York Supreme Court December 1, 1995 (Scarsdale v. Jorling)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-12-1995
OPINION OF THE COURT
Donald N. Silverman, J.
The instant matter was originally commenced pursuant to CPLR article 78. It seeks various forms of relief including mandamus to review, mandamus to compel, and prohibition. Specifically, petitioner originally sought to: (1) annul and cancel an interim decision of respondent Thomas Jorling rendered on November 22, 1994, which held, in part, that the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) lacked administrative authority to address (a) the imposition as of July 1, 1992 of increased water rate(s) charged to petitioner by *4the New York City Water Board (the Board), (b) the issue of excess water consumption including the method of calculating the amounts of both entitlement and excess water, and (c) the resolution of disputes over the rate for excess water charged by the Board; (2) declare the higher rates imposed by the Board as of July 1, 1992 to be unlawful; (3) direct the DEC to address and resolve the issues of excess per capita water consumption under the authority of Administrative Code of the City of New York § 24-360, also known as the Water Supply Act of 1905 (the Act); and (4) as an alternative, a declaration granting the same relief in the event the DEC is without jurisdiction.
This court, in its prior decision-judgment of January 31, 1995, elected to treat this matter as an action for declaratory judgment. The instant decision-judgment accordingly treats this application as one for declaratory judgment.
By decision-order of May 4, 1995 this court permitted the County of Westchester to intervene as a petitioner-intervenor. The petition of Westchester sought the same declaratory relief to the extent that it sought to have the rate increase for entitlement water declared unlawful. Although the original motion to intervene was unopposed, respondents seek to dismiss this claim for failing to state a cause of action under CPLR 7803 and as untimely.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit