Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit June 5, 1995, 723, Docket 94-7605 (Chase Manhattan Bank, N.A. v. Celotex Corporation and U.S. Mineral Products Company, Dana Corporation)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-06-1995
WINTER, Circuit Judge:
Chase Manhattan Bank, N.A. (“Chase”) appeals from Judge Broderick’s grant of summary judgment for. Dana Corporation (“Dana”). The underlying dispute concerns damage to a building owned by Chase that has asbestos-containing materials, some of which were allegedly manufactured by Dana. Judge Broderick held that Chase’s claim was precluded by the doctrine of
res judicata
because a substantially identical lawsuit brought by the prior owner of the building, the New York Plaza Budding Company (“NYPBC”), was abandoned with prejudice. We hold the doctrine of
res judicata
inapplicable because Chase at all times owned an option to purchase the building that was “in the money.” That is, the option provided a right to purchase the building at a price substantially below market value. Consequently, after Chase’s purchase of the budding, NYPBC had little incentive to pursue its action because it could not show that the sale price was diminished because of the presence of asbestos. Chase is thus not precluded from asserting its claim.
Briefly stated, the facts are as fodows. On March 13, 1967, before completion of the construction of the budding in question, One New York Plaza, Chase executed a lease and option with NYPBC. The option gave Chase the right to purchase the budding on certain dates at a price set by a stipulated formula. After the budding was completed, the presence of asbestos was determined to be harmful. However, at all pertinent times, the option was “in the money,” notwithstanding any reduction in the building’s market value due to the presence of asbestos.
In 1987, Chase brought the present action for property damage in the Southern District against three asbestos manufacturers, U.S. Mineral Products Company, Celotex Corporation, and Dana. At or near the same time, NYPBC brought a simdar property damage
*345
action against the same three asbestos manufacturers, also in the Southern District.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit