Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit May 25, 1995, 1474, Docket 94-7955 (Result Shipping Co., Ltd. v. Ferruzzi Trading USA Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-05-1995
JON 0. NEWMAN, Chief Judge:
This appeal concerns the scope of the District Court’s discretion in deciding whether to grant security and/or countersecurity to a defendant-counterclaimant in an admiralty proceeding brought in aid of arbitration. The issue arises on an appeal by defendant Ferruzzi Trading USA Inc. (“Ferruzzi”) from an order entered on August 24, 1994, by the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut (Alan H. Nevas, Judge). Plaintiff Result Shipping Co. (“Result”) commenced the action by attaching Ferruzzi’s property to secure an
in personam
admiralty claim against Ferruzzi. In its August 24 order, the District Court denied Ferruzzi’s motion for security for costs related to the attachment and for countersecurity on its counterclaims against Result, and granted Result’s motion to stay the proceedings pending arbitration of the dispute between the parties.
On appeal, Ferruzzi contends that the District Court denied its motion for security and countersecurity solely because the underlying dispute was to be resolved in arbitration, and that denying the motion on this basis represented a reversible failure to exercise the Court’s discretion. Ferruzzi also contends that the District Court’s denial of security to cover its costs related to the attachment fails to comport with the requirements of due process. With respect to the denial of security for costs, we reject Ferruzzi’s arguments and affirm that part of the District Court’s order. We find more merit, however, in Ferruzzi’s argument that the District Court denied its motion for countersecurity solely because the underlying dispute was subject to arbitration. Because we hold that the arbitrability of a dispute is not relevant to a decision whether to grant countersecurity to a defendant under these circumstances, we vacate and remand this part of the District Court’s order.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit