Court of Special Appeals of Maryland December 1, 1995, No. 146 (Lane v. Bethlehem Steel Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-12-1995
ALPERT, Judge,
Specially Assigned.
In this case, we are called upon to decide whether an employer/premises owner can discharge his duty to warn an independent contractor’s employee of a latent danger by warning the independent contractor or his supervisory personnel.
*271Mr. Carroll Lane (“Lane”), an employee of BMI, Inc., an independent contractor, suffered work-related injuries while working for BMI, Inc. (“BMI”), which had been contracted to maintain the coke ovens at Bethlehem Steel Corporation’s Sparrows Point Steel Plant. The unfortunate industrial accident and the events that transpired thereafter gave rise to a lawsuit filed by Lane, the injured worker, against Bethlehem Steel Corporation (“Bethlehem”).
The resulting jury trial, presided over by the Honorable Lawrence R. Daniels, Circuit Court for Baltimore County, closed with the jury returning verdicts in Bethlehem’s favor.
In this appeal, Lane presents three questions.
I. Did the trial court err in instructing that if the jury found that [Lane] was injured solely as a result of his employer’s failure to supervise [ ] properly, they must find [Bethlehem] not negligent?
II. Was there legally sufficient evidence to support the trial court’s instruction that the jury must find [Bethlehem] not negligent if it found that [Lane] was injured due to a dangerous condition about which he knew o[r] should have known?
III. Did the evidence compel the conclusion that [Bethlehem] was negligent as a matter of law?
Our discussion as to the first issue answers the second issue in the affirmative; Lane was charged with the knowledge of his employer, BMI, the independent contractor. As to the third issue, certainly reasonable minds could differ as to whether BMI was warned of the potential dangers; if it was warned, then, based upon the law as explicated under the first issue, Bethlehem was not negligent.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit