Court of Special Appeals of Maryland December 27, 1995, No. 1987 (Department of Public Safety & Correctional Services v. Ara Health Services, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-12-1995
HOLLANDER, Judge.
This case concerns a contract dispute between the State and a company that provided health care to prison inmates. The State, acting through the Division of Correction (“DOC”) of the Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services (“the Department”), appellant, had a contract with ARA Health Services, Inc., d/b/a Correctional Medical Systems (“CMS”), appellee, to provide medical care to inmates incarcerated in Maryland correctional facilities. At issue is CMS’s claim for reimbursement for the cost of AIDS medication. After the Board of Contract Appeals denied CMS’s contract claim, CMS sought review in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City. The court reversed, based on a contractual “modification by conduct,” and entered judgment in favor of CMS in the amount of $135,446.00. In its appeal, the Department presents the following questions for our consideration:
I. Did the Circuit Court exceed its authority when it rejected the Board of Contract Appeals’s factual finding that the parties’ conduct did not constitute a modification and substituted its own factual findings and judgment that the conduct did constitute a modification?
II. Does sovereign immunity bar an action based on an unwritten modification to a written contract when the contract and State regulations require that all modifications to the contract be in writing and approved by the Board of Public Works?
We conclude that the circuit court erred in finding that the parties’ conduct constituted a modification of the contract. We are also of the view that sovereign immunity bars appellee’s action. As we answer both questions in the affirmative, we shall reverse.
*450
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The DOC issued a “Request for Proposals” in September 1988, in which it solicited bids from contractors to provide health care services to Maryland prisoners. CMS was awarded Contract No. 8804-00 (“the Contract”), which the parties executed in November 1988.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit