United States District Court for the District of Arkansas September 1, 1995, Bankruptcy No. 88-41050-11; No. 94-4253-RDR (American Freight System, Inc. v. Electrolert, Inc. (In re American Freight System, Inc.))
Also known as
United States · · · 01-09-1995
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
ROGERS, District Judge.
This is a bankruptcy appeal. This appeal arises from an adversary proceeding filed by debtor, American Freight System, Inc. against the appellant in this matter, Electro-lert, Inc., to recover freight charges allegedly owed to debtor. Electrolert asserts that the freight charges were the subject of a release agreed to by debtor and Electrolert to settle litigation filed by Electrolert against debtor before the underlying bankruptcy was filed. The bankruptcy judge denied Electrolert’s motion for summary judgment finding that the language of the settlement agreement was ambiguous. After conducting a trial in which only one witness (the chief executive officer of Electrolert) was presented, the bankruptcy judge held that Electrolert had not satisfied its burden of proving the settlement covered the disputed freight charges and, therefore, held in favor of debtor. Elec-trolert appeals the bankruptcy judge’s rul*694ings on its summary judgment motion and at trial.
The following facts appear uncontroverted. Electrolert sued debtor after a shipment of Electrolert products (“fuzzbusters”) was lost. Electrolert sought $83,616.00 in damages for the lost shipment. Before filing the litigation, Electrolert continued to hire debtor to ship its goods. However, Electrolert did not pay debtor for several of the shipments. The CEO for Electrolert, Mr. Dale Smith, testified that payment for the shipments was intentionally withheld pending the resolution of the dispute over the lost shipment. The litigation filed by Electrolert was settled.
The settlement document, titled “MUTUAL RELEASE”, reads as follows:
This Agreement made and concluded as of the date of the last execution hereof by the parties, by and between Electrolert, Inc., American Freight Systems, Inc., Steve D. Thompson Trucking, Inc., and Service Merchandise Company, Inc., and Wholesale Supply Company, Inc.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit