District Court, D. Puerto Rico May 9, 1995, Civ. No. 91-2216CCC (Ortiz v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-05-1995
ORDER
CEREZO, Chief Judge.
This action, filed pursuant to the Federal Tort Claims Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2671 et seq., arises from injuries suffered by Eduardo Ortiz on August 23, 1987 when a military ordnance device handed to him by one of his sons exploded in his hand. The accident occurred in restricted waters off the north coast of Pifieros Island, adjacent to and part of the restricted area of the Roosevelt Roads Navy Base at Ceiba, Puerto Rico. The plaintiffs had arrived there in their pleasure boat, accompanied by three other families who had their own boats.
A bench trial was held on April 21-23, 1993. The defendant submitted its post-trial brief on September 26, 1994; plaintiffs’ brief followed on October 25, 1994.1
The uncontroverted facts of the incident are as follows:
Pifieros Island, approximately one-half square mile in size, is used for military training exercises. Retired Master Chief Thomas Keith, formerly attached to Naval Special Warfare Unit (Navy SEALS), prior to his retirement in late 1992 after 31 years of service, had himself conducted some 50 to 60 classes there dealing with unconventional warfare tactics and techniques, and the use of explosives and devices. An expert on the military training sessions conducted on the Island, he stated that the sessions would take place, primarily at night, for a week at a time between six to nine times a year. When the session ended, the entire class would make sweeps through the areas they had been using to pick up expended ordnance or any ordnance inadvertently left behind. He explained that training sessions are held on the Island, and not elsewhere on the base, specifically because it is an unpopulated Island. The ordnance, explosives, and explosive devices cannot be used in populated areas.
On the day of the accident, the OrtizMéndez family anchored their boat about 40 feet from the shore of the Island.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit