District Court, S.D. New York March 3, 1995, Nos. 86 Civ. 3834 (LAK), 87 Civ. 5044 (LAK) (Denise v. Eli Lilly & Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-03-1995
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
KAPLAN, District Judge.
This is a product liability case arising out of injury allegedly sustained by Denise Rubel as a result of her mother’s use during her pregnancy of diethylstilbesterol. The case is scheduled for trial on March 9, 1995. The matter is before the Court on plaintiffs’ application, dated March 1, 1995 and made pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 32(a)(3)(E), for leave to read in evidence the 1988-89 deposition testimony of Dr. Lawrence Jackman, who treated Mrs. Rubel from May 1976 through September 1980, despite the fact that Dr. Jackman practices in this District and is within one hundred miles of the courthouse.
Although Dr. Jackman was deposed in this case, he was expected by all parties to testify in person at the trial. The current application is based on an affidavit of Dr. Jackman, who states that he practices in a group of four physicians, that he currently is handling the entire practice alone, and that he therefore cannot leave his practice to testify in court. Within the last two weeks, one of his three colleagues retired for physical reasons and a second left on maternity leave. The third was hospitalized on February 14, 1995 with an as-yet undiagnosed illness.
Defendant Eli Lilly and Co. opposes the application. It contends that it conducted a discovery deposition of Dr. Jackman in view of his presence in the District and his amenability to process. It maintains that the effect of permitting use of the deposition therefore would be to deprive it of any effective cross-examination. It suggests also that Dr. Jack-man’s claimed unavailability is more a product of plaintiffs’ desire to avoid subjecting him to cross-examination than of the demands of his practice.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit