West Virginia Supreme Court July 12, 1996, 23052, 23053 (Hartley Marine Corp. v. Mierke)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-07-1996

WORKMAN, Justice.

Hartley Marine Corp. (“Hartley Marine”), The Ohio River Company (“ORCO”), and Crounse Corporation (“Crounse”) appeal

1

from orders entered by the Circuit Court of Kanawha County on January 30, 1995, and

*672

February 8, 1995, affirming the administrative decisions of the State Tax Commissioner which denied Appellants’ petitions seeking refunds of West Virginia fuel use tax payments and affirmed an assessment of additional fuel use tax against Hartley Marine. Appellants contend that imposition of the fuel use tax against them violates the Supremacy, Commerce, Due Process, Equal Protection, and Duty of Tonnage Clauses of the United States Constitution, and is further prohibited by the Northwest Ordinance of 1787 and the Virginia Compact of 1789. Upon review of these claims, we find no impediment, constitutional or otherwise, to the imposition of the fuel use tax against Appellants. Accordingly, we affirm the decision of the lower court.

West Virginia Code § ll-15A-13(a)(2) (1995) imposes an excise tax

2

on the “use or consumption in this state of gasoline or special fuel purchased outside this state at the rate of five percent of the average wholesale price of such gasoline or special fuel....” A minimum wholesale price for purposes of computing the tax is fixed by statute at ninety-seven cents per gallon. W. Va.Code § ll-15A-13(a)(l). Every motor carrier operating in West Virginia is required to pay the excise tax on all gasoline or special fuel used within the state. W. Va.Code § 11-15A-13(d).

Appellants are motor carriers as defined by West Virginia Code § 11 — 15—18(c)(6) (1995)

3

who are engaged in the business of transporting products by watercraft in interstate commerce on the Ohio and Mississippi River systems. Appellants’ watercraft

4

operate within this state while traveling on the Ohio River.

5

The sole means of propulsion for Appellants’ watercraft is either gasoline or special fuel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.