District Court, D. Connecticut February 9, 1996, Civil 3:94CV2178 (PCD) (Andreucci v. City of New Haven)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-02-1996

RULING ON PENDING MOTIONS

DORSEY, Chief Judge.

Defendants move for summary judgment on plaintiffs’ due process and equal protection .claims, and plaintiffs cross-move for summary judgment on the due process claim. For the reasons below, defendants’ and plaintiffs’ motions are, respectively, granted and denied.

I. BACKGROUND

Plaintiffs are New Haven firefighters. Six plaintiffs were promoted to the rank of lieutenant in 1988 and 1989, and two plaintiffs were appointed as battalion chiefs in 1988. Plaintiffs served in these positions for periods of up to five years.

Under the city charter, promotions must be made from eligibility lists which are valid for at most two years. Plaintiffs’ promotion eligibility lists were dated March 31, 1986. Just under two years later, on March 30, 1988, plaintiffs’ promotions were approved “subject to assignment.” This was in accordance with a longstanding practice of approving promotions just before a list expired but delaying assignment to the new position until a vacancy existed. Once a vacancy occurred, a firefighter would be assigned to the higher office and paid accordingly. .

In 1989, several firefighters filed a suit challenging the practice of filling vacancies from expired lists. The firefighters alleged that this practice unlawfully denied promotions to firefighters who became eligible for promotion after the list was constructed. The trial court ruled that “promotions made subject to assignment” were unlawful and null and void. In consequence, plaintiffs’ promotions to lieutenant and battalion chief positions were voided, and they were, and have been, relegated to the positions, duties, and pay to which they were formerly assigned. The trial court’s ruling was sustained by the Connecticut Appellate Court and Connecticut Supreme Court.

New Haven Firebird, Soc’y v. Bd. of Fire Comm’rs of New Haven, 32

Conn.App. 585, 630 A.2d 131 (1993),

appeal denied,

228 Conn. 902, 634 A.2d 295 (1993).

II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.