Court of Appeals of Kentucky March 15, 1996, 94-CA-001822-MR (Shortridge v. Rice)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1996
HUDDLESTON, Judge.
This ease involves a collision between two automobiles at a Prestonsburg, Kentucky, intersection. The drivers, Barbara Shortridge and Morris Rice, both claim to have had a green light as they approached the intersection from opposite directions. The collision occurred when Shortridge attempted to make a left turn across Rice’s path at the intersection.
Both Shortridge and Christy Thorpe, a witness to the accident, testified that on January 11, 1993, at about 9:00 p.m., Rice entered the intersection driving, without lights, at an excessive rate of speed. While Rice admits that his headlights were not working after the accident, he claims that prior to the collision he was using his headlights and was driving between twenty and twenty-five miles per hour. Rice attempted to undermine the testimony of Shortridge and Thorpe by pointing out that both admitted that they did not see Rice’s vehicle before it entered the intersection. Nevertheless, Rice admitted that he had consumed alcohol prior to the accident. Confirming Rice’s intoxication, a police officer testified that Rice had slurred speech, failed three sobriety tests and was trying to put a Budweiser box behind his seat when police arrived at the scene of the accident.
Alleging negligence and wanton conduct, Shortridge brought this personal injury action against Rice. The issues of liability and damages were submitted to a jury. Apportioning fault equally between Rice and Shor-tridge, the jury returned a verdict awarding Shortridge $5,000.00 of her alleged $18,000.00 medical expenses, but did not award any damages for pain and suffering. After Shor-tridge’s attorney made repeated requests for reconsideration of the zero award for pain and suffering, the court ordered the jury to reconsider the issue. Thereafter, the jury awarded Shortridge $1,000.00 for pain and suffering.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit