Court of Appeals of Wisconsin April 9, 1996, 95-2428-CR (State v. Bustamante)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1996

CANE, P.J.

Sebastian "Frank" Bustamante appeals his conviction for second-degree murder of his son, Jason, contrary to § 940.02(1), Stats., 1977,

1

after a jury trial. Bustamante argues the trial court

*567

improperly admitted other acts evidence that unfairly prejudiced his defense and, therefore, his conviction should be reversed and the case should be remanded for a new trial. We disagree and affirm the conviction.

Jason was nearly one year old in 1978 when his parents, Bustamante and Mary Hunt, took him to the hospital because he was pale, rigid and unresponsive. When they arrived at the emergency room, Dr. John Cassidy examined Jason. Cassidy testified at trial that Jason was comatose and could not be aroused to anything resembling consciousness. Jason died from his injuries three days later. Dr. Darrell Skarphol conducted an autopsy and later testified that Jason died from severe head injuries, including two wide, long skull fractures.

The State's theory was that Bustamante injured Jason earlier on the day he was brought to the hospital by either shaking, striking or throwing the child in the child's bedroom while Mary was unloading groceries in the kitchen. Although Bustamante did not testify at trial, he told police during the investigation that he and Mary both heard a thump and ran into Jason's bedroom where they found Jason on the floor, having apparently fallen from his crib.

2

At trial, the State introduced "other acts" evidence that Bustamante was involved in the abuse of another young child. The incident occurred in Milwaukee in 1989, when Bustamante was living with his girlfriend, Laura, and Laura's newborn daughter, Bianca T. Laura testified she took Bianca to the hospital after Bianca became fussy and refused to eat. Dr. Shelly Wernick testified that she examined Bianca and

*568

determined that Bianca had a skull fracture, blood clots over her brain and bruising of the brain itself.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.