District of Columbia Court of Appeals March 28, 1996, 94-FS-1079, 94-FS-1566 (In Re DR)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-03-1996

673 A.2d 1259 (1996) In re D.R., Da.R., Appellants. Nos. 94-FS-1079, 94-FS-1566. District of Columbia Court of Appeals. Submitted November 28, 1995. Decided March 28, 1996. *1260 Madeleine Tolmach, Washington, DC, was on the brief, for appellant. Iris McCollum Green, Washington, DC, was on the brief, for appellee. Before FERREN, TERRY, and FARRELL, Associate Judges. PER CURIAM: After reviewing this proceeding to terminate Da.R.'s parental rights with respect to her daughter, D.R., we conclude that the judgment should be affirmed. In particular, we conclude for the reasons set forth in Parts I., II.A., and II.B. of Judge FERREN'S opinion that there was sufficient evidence for the trial court to apply D.C.Code § 16-2353(b)(2) (1989 Repl.) relating to the physical, mental, and emotional health of the parties involved, and that Da.R.'s Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination was not violated. We further conclude, for the reasons expressed in Part II.C.(1) of Judge FERREN'S opinion, that the trial court erred in declining to apply D.C.Code § 16-2353(b)(5) (concerning evidence of continued drug activity in D.R.'s "home environment") simply on the ground that D.R., as a boarder baby, see id. § 16-2353(b)(3)(A) (1995 Supp.), "never went home." On the other hand, as set forth in Judge FARRELL'S opinion, we reject Da.R.'s contention that, under D.C.Code § 16-2353(b)(5), the District of Columbia must satisfy her statutory right to treatment for drug abuse before termination of her parental rights. In accord with Judge FARRELL'S opinion, we conclude — for reasons different from the trial court's analysis — that § 16-2353(b)(5) does not stand in the way of terminating Da.R.'s parental rights on the facts of this case, and that the trial court did *1261 not err in denying Da.R.'s motions for a continuance and for a new trial. Affirmed. FERREN, Associate Judge, concurring in part and dissenting in part: D.R.'s biological mother, Da.R.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.