Supreme Court of New Jersey July 3, 1996 (State v. Diaz)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1996

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

COLEMAN, J.

The issue raised in this appeal is whether a conviction for possession of a firearm for an unlawful purpose should merge with a conviction for passion/provocation manslaughter when the trial court did not instruct the jury with respect to an unlawful purpose that was broader than, and separate from, using the firearm to commit the homicide.

We hold that failure to use a special verdict is not dispositive of the merger issue. Merger is not required when the evidence submitted to the jury is sufficient to permit it to determine that defendant possessed the firearm for an unlawful purpose independent of the greater offense, here a homicide, and when the jury has been properly instructed and those instructions do not restrict the jury’s consideration of the unlawful purpose only to commission of the greater offense for which defendant was found guilty.

/

Defendant was twenty-two years old when he injured his hand in a brawl and had to wear a cast. A few days after that fight, he was walking through a crowded playground when Gregory Ricky Gordon bumped into defendant’s injured hand. Defendant believed that Gordon deliberately bumped into his hand to show

*633

disrespect. According to defendant, Gordon then taunted him about being injured in the prior brawl.

After the encounter with Gordon, defendant left the playground for less than one half hour and returned with two friends, Orlando Diaz and Anticious “Shorty” McGhee. Defendant knew before reentering the playground that Shorty was carrying a handgun.

Defendant approached Gordon and warned that he had a gun. Gordon retorted that he also had a gun. Defendant threatened Gordon to stay away before defendant “put something in [Gordon] they [cannot] take out.” In response, Gordon jeered at defendant. Defendant and Gordon exchanged angry words and began to fight. Shorty fired one shot into the air.

Very shortly after firing that shot, Shorty handed the gun to defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.