Supreme Court of New Jersey May 20, 1996 (In THE MATTER OF APPLICATION OF McLAUGHLIN)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-05-1996

The opinion of the court was delivered by

HANDLER, J.

This is a bar-admissions case. It arises from the report and recommendation of the Supreme Court Committee on Character that the required certification of good character be withheld from a candidate for the July 1994 New Jersey Bar Examination. The recommendation was based on the Committee’s conclusion that the candidate did not demonstrate the fitness and good character essential for the practice of law.

The ease requires the Court to explain the standards for evaluating character and fitness for the practice of law, and to reemphasize the importance of these requisites for admission to the bar. More specifically, the Court must address truthfulness and respect for the administration of justice as traits of character and fitness that are deemed indispensable to a lawyer.

I

Frank B. McLaughlin sat for the July 1994 New Jersey Bar Exam. Mr. McLaughlin (“McLaughlin” or “candidate”) was a graduate of Rutgers Law School-Newark where he was Book Review Editor of the Rutgers Law Review. Before attending law school, McLaughlin was a claims analyst for American Reinsurance in Princeton, New Jersey, from October 1988 to Septem

*137

ber 1991. Following his graduation from law school, he completed and submitted his application to sit for the July exam on May 29, 1994. His application was reviewed in normal course. A routine fingerprint cheek revealed a prior arrest that was apparently not disclosed in McLaughlin’s application. The Committee on Character, established under

Rule

1:25 to assess the character qualifications of candidates for admission to the bar, reviewed the candidate’s application in an informal conference pursuant to Regulation 303 of the Regulations Governing the Committee on Character

(RG

303). Although the Court has determined that the July 1991 version of the Regulations should be applied to McLaughlin’s application, references will be made herein to more current Regulations.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.