District Court, S.D. New York March 4, 1996, 95 Civ. 5179 (LAK) (Levin v. McPhee)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-03-1996

OPINION

KAPLAN, District Judge.

In this action, Ilya D. Levin, plaintiff, contends that he was libeled by statements made in a book entitled The Ransom of Russian Aet, by defendant John McPhee. The book was published by defendant Far-rar, Straus & Giroux (“Farrar”) and excerpted in an article with the same title published by defendant The New Yorker Magazine, Inc. (the

“The New Yorker

”). Plaintiff complains that the portions of the book and the article pertaining to the mysterious death of a noted Russian dissident artist, Evgeny Rukhin, charge plaintiff with cowardice and with involvement in causing the deaths of Rukhin and Rukhin’s friend, Ludmila Bobl-yak. Plaintiff contends further that the defendants intentionally inflicted emotional distress upon him by writing and publishing the book and the article. This Court has jurisdiction as a result of the diversity of the parties’ citizenship.

The case is now before the Court on the defendants’ motion to dismiss the complaint. Defendants urge that the book and the article, each of which presents multiple theories regarding the cause of Rukhin’s death, are incapable as a matter of law of the defamatory construction plaintiff gives to them and that the statements complained of are protected expressions of opinion. McPhee and

The New Yorker

contend further that the complaint should be dismissed as against them because the statements complained of are substantially true and, to the extent that they are not, that they caused plaintiff only incremental harm. McPhee and Farrar contend that they are protected by a privilege of neutral reportage. Plaintiff has cross-moved for summary judgment on the question whether the publications are capable of a defamatory meaning or, in the alternative, for leave to amend.

Facts

John McPhee is a prominent author, described-by his counsel as one of the most distinguished figures in American letters.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.