California Court of Appeal June 14, 1996, F023815 (Van Dyke v. Dunker & Aced)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-06-1996

Opinion

THAXTER, J.

This professional malpractice action arises from erroneous income tax advice allegedly given by defendant accountants. Relying on the advice, the plaintiffs made a charitable contribution. When their income tax returns for the period were prepared and filed, they learned the advice was incorrect and they incurred taxes greater than expected. The trial court granted summary judgment for the defendants, concluding that the plaintiffs both discovered the negligence and suffered actual injury when they filed the tax return and paid their taxes. Because that occurred more than two years before they filed their complaint, the action was time-barred by Code of Civil Procedure section 339, subdivision l.

1

We will agree with the trial court and affirm. The “bright line” rule adopted by the Supreme Court in

International Engine Parts, Inc.

v.

Feddersen & Co.

(1995) 9 Cal.4th 606 [38 Cal.Rptr.2d 150, 888 P.2d 1279] (Feddersen), for cases based on negligent preparation of returns, does not apply here.

Facts and Procedural History

According to the allegations of the first amended complaint, Dunker and Aced, an accountancy corporation, and Galen Gray, an accountant, (collectively respondents) agreed to provide tax advice and prepare 1989 and 1990 tax returns for Kenneth and Roberta Van Dyke (appellants). During that period, respondents “. . . negligently advised [appellants] to donate real estate worth $125,000.00, in order to receive a tax deduction of equal value . . . [and] negligently advised [appellants] that they could deduct the full

*449

$125,000.00 from their tax obligations for 1989 and 1990." After appellants donated the property, respondents advised them they “could only deduct a portion” of the property’s value and the “credit against taxes would have to be prorated over 10 years.” As a result of respondents’ negligence, appellants “received only a tax credit of about $23,250.00 resulting in damages of approximately $102,750.00, plus interest. .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.