Supreme Judicial Court of Maine March 12, 1996 (Kraul v. Maine Bonding & Casualty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1996

ROBERTS, Justice.

Plaintiffs Karl Kraul and his mother, Sandra Bouthiet, appeal from a summary judgment entered in the Superior Court (Cumberland County,

Bradford, J.)

in favor of the defendants, Maine Bonding & Casualty Company; Roger C. Legere; and an independent insurance agency, Blake, Hall & Sprague, Inc., on the plaintiffs’ consolidated actions seeking damages for perjury pursuant to 14 M.R.S.A. § 870 (1980). The plaintiffs argue that the court erred in construing section 870 and in holding that the judgment in the previous trial was not based on perjured testimony. We affirm the judgment.

In 1978 Karl Kraul was severely injured when he dove into a swimming pool sold and installed by Kasu Corporation, a company that ceased doing business in 1977. The plaintiffs obtained a default judgment against Kasu. While in business, Kasu was insured by Maine Bonding and had obtained the policy through the insurance agency. The policy had expired before the accident and consequently Maine Bonding refused to defend Kasu in the suit.

1

In 1985 the plaintiffs brought an action against Maine Bonding to reach and apply the insurance coverage. At the same time, the plaintiffs as assignees of Kasu commenced an action against Maine Bonding for breach of contract, negligence, and punitive damages. The court

(Wemick, AR.J.)

granted a summary judgment to Maine Bonding in both actions. We affirmed the judgment in the reach and apply action.

Kraul v. Maine Bonding & Casualty Co.,

559 A.2d 338 (Me.1989)

(Kraul I).

The court allowed the plaintiffs, as assignees, to amend their complaint to include claims based on implied contract and estoppel. Following a jury trial the court directed a verdict in favor of Maine Bonding and we affirmed the judgment.

Kraul v. Maine Bonding & Casualty Co.,

600 A.2d 389, 391 (Me.1991)

(Kraul II), cert. denied,

504 U.S. 959, 112 S.Ct. 2311, 119 L.Ed.2d 232 (1992).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.