District Court, S.D. Texas April 24, 1996, Civil Action H-95-1245 (Royal Indemnity Insurance v. Mikob Properties, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-04-1996
MEMORANDUM AND OPINION
ROSENTHAL, District Judge.
Pending before this court in this insurance coverage dispute are cross-motions for partial summary judgment filed by plaintiff Royal Indemnity Insurance Co. (Docket Entry No. 30) and defendant Mikob Properties, Inc. D/B/A Balboa Apartments (Docket Entry No. 27). Based on the pleadings, motions, submissions, and applicable law, this court DENIES defendant’s motion and GRANTS plaintiff’s motion, for the reasons stated below.
I. Background
Defendant Mikob Properties, Inc. D/B/A Balboa Apartments (“Mikob”) owns and manages an apartment complex containing three separate apartment buildings. The complex is located in Nassau Bay, Harris County, Texas. On February 19, 1995, a fire completely destroyed one of the three apartment buildings, Building C. The two other apartment buddings, Buildings A and B, had only minor damage.
After the fire, Mikob erected a fence around what remained of Budding C and the surrounding area. When asbestos was discovered in the soot from the fire, the Texas Health Department insisted that Budding C remain fenced off untd the budding could be demolished and the area around it cleaned. Since the fire, tenants have been unable to use amenities located near Budding C, including a lighted boardwalk, a lighted fishing pier, a boat ramp, a picnic area, and a parking area previously used by Budding B tenants. (Docket Entry No. 29, Affidavit of Adan Klein, vice president of Mikob, Exhibit B). Mikob asserts that these amenities con
*156
tributed to the overall appeal of the complex as a waterfront community.
Before the fire, the apartment complex was 94.29 percent occupied. Since the fire, no unit in Budding C has been habitable and the budding has been vacant. It is undisputed that every unit in Buddings A and B remained habitable. However, the occupancy rates of Buddings A and B have decreased. The occupancy rate for Budding A was 96.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit