Supreme Court of Oklahoma September 24, 1996, 85045 (Calvert v. Tulsa Public Schools, Independent School District No. 1 of Tulsa County)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-09-1996

SUMMERS, Justice:

The case turns on whether the Plaintiffs, parents of a deceased child, may proceed with their suit against the School District in the District Court. The trial court, and the Court of Appeals, took the position that the parents’ failure to have themselves appointed as personal representatives of their daughter’s estate until after the running of the statute of limitations was fatal to their claim, even though the parents had otherwise timely brought the suit. Corollary to the issue is whether the parents’ notice to the School District was sufficient under the Governmental Tort Claims Act. We reverse, and allow the action to proceed.

Ten-year old LaQuita Calvert died of a severe asthma attack while at school. In their capacity as parents and heirs of LaQui-ta, Plaintiffs brought suit against the School District under the Governmental Tort Claims Act for her death, claiming that LaQuita’s requests for assistance immediately prior to her death were ignored by school officials. The School District filed a motion for summary judgment. It urged that the parents were not the proper parties to bring the action, and that the Governmental Tort Claims Act required that the suit be brought by an administrator or personal representative. About a year and a half after the death of LaQuita, and after the filing of this ease, the parents were appointed as personal representatives. After their appointment as personal representatives the Calverts filed a motion to amend their original petition, to show their status as such.

The District Court denied the motion to amend and granted summary judgment in favor of the School, holding that only an administrator or personal representative could bring suit under the Governmental Tort Claims Act. Because the parents had not been appointed by a court as personal representatives until after the time limit had run for bringing an action under the Act, that Court held the suit was barred.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.