Texas Attorney General Reports July 2, 1996, DM-414 (Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-1996

QBfficeof the !Zlttornep @eneral

Mate of Gexae

DAN MORALES

Al-roRxEY

CESERAL September 23.1996

Mr. Bany R. McBee Opiion No. DM-4 14

Chair, Texas Natural Resource

Conservation Commission Re: Whether the state constitutionally

P.O. Box 13087 may implement, as part of its vehicle

Austin, Texas 7871 l-3087 emissions inspection and maintenance

program, a federal requirement that the

state temporarily may suspend station or

inspector licenses immediately upon finding

a violation of the program or equipment

failure (RQ-894)

Dear Mr. McBee:

Federal law requires the state to authorize a quality assurance officer of the state’s

vehicle emissions inspection and maintenance program temporarily to suspend the license

of an inspection station or inspector immediately, and prior to providing a hearing, upon

discovering that the station or inspector has violated the state’s program or that the station

or inspector has suffered an equipment failure that directly affects emission reduction

benefits. You ask whether the immediate, temporary suspension requirement violates the

due-process clause of article I, section 19 of the Texas Constitution. We conclude that it

does not unless it violates the federal constitution’s due-process requirements. While we

believe a court would fmd the immediate, temporary suspension requirement

constitutional, whether in a particular case the state applies the requirement so as to

violate the federal constitution is a question off% that is inappropriate to the opinion

process.

Before we address the constitutional issue you raise, we believe it will be helpfil to

examine the pertinent federal laws regarding a state’s creation of a vehicle emissions

inspection and maintenance program.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.