Missouri Court of Appeals May 21, 1996, No. WD 51065 (State ex rel. Mohart v. Romano)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1996

ORIGINAL PROCEEDING IN PROHIBITION

BRECKENRIDGE, Presiding Judge.

Relator Robert Mohart filed a petition in prohibition to prevent respondent, the Honorable Anthony J. Romano, Associate Circuit Judge of Jackson County, from executing an order of criminal contempt which was issued against him. Mr. Mohart contends that *538Judge Romano erred by finding him to be in criminal contempt for violating orders which were beyond the jurisdiction of the court which issued them, since Mr. Mohart could not be held in contempt for violating void orders. Mr. Mohart also contends that the underlying orders were issued in violation of the separation of powers doctrine, and that the order of criminal contempt was erroneous because there was no evidence of willfulness or contumacy on his part. This court issued a preliminary order in prohibition, and such order is now made absolute.

This petition arises from prior judicial proceedings involving the early release of prisoners from Kansas City, Missouri’s Municipal Correctional Institution (“M.C.I.”). These prisoners included David Duly, who, on January 20, 1992, was charged with violating a municipal ordinance which prohibited driving while under the influence of intoxicating liquor. Mr. Duly was found guilty in municipal court and appealed his conviction to the circuit court. Mr. Duly then pleaded guilty to the DUI charge and was placed on probation. Judge Romano, who was the sentencing judge in Mr. Duly’s case, eventually revoked Mr. Duly’s probation and ordered Mr. Duly to serve 180 days at M.C.I. Mr. Duly entered M.C.I. on September 22,1993.

Fifty-three days later, on November 13, 1993, Mr. Duly was unconditionally paroled by Mr. Mohart, who was the acting director of the city’s neighborhood and community services department, and by Mr. Theodore Heflin, who was the acting superintendent of M.C.I. Mr. Duly’s early release was explained as part of an ongoing effort to alleviate overcrowding at M.C.I.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.