New York Supreme Court January 30, 1996 (People v. Salzarulo)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-01-1996

OPINION OF THE COURT

Bernard J. Fried, J.

Defendants, all officers of Plumber’s Local Union No. 2 (Local 2), who are charged in a 183-count indictment with enterprise corruption (Penal Law § 460.20) and related crimes, move to suppress evidence obtained through court-authorized electronic eavesdropping.

In November 1990, after the investigation into alleged labor racketeering and other illegal conduct involving the plumbing industry had been underway for some time, the District Attorney applied for, and obtained, an order authorizing the installation of pen registers on three public telephones located at the Pelham Bay Diner in the Bronx. As required under CPL 705.10, there was the requisite showing of "reasonable suspicion” to authorize the use of a pen register in order to identify the telephone numbers dialed. This authorization was further extended in January 1991, and ultimately the District Attorney requested, and obtained, an eavesdropping warrant on the same telephones in February 1991, which was extended seven times through October 1991.

During the electronic surveillance at the Pelham Bay Diner, in July 1991, an order was obtained authorizing the installation of a pen register on the residential telephones of defendants Frank Martello, Peter Bishop and Melvin Goldsmith. In September 1991, eavesdropping warrants were obtained concerning these residential telephones. This electronic surveillance was extended, by court orders issued in October and November and amended in October to include Paul Martello. In January 1992, eavesdropping was discontinued on the telephones of Paul Martello and Peter Bishop, although the pen register orders were continued; the other eavesdropping warrants were also extended. In February 1992, a further warrant extension was obtained, limited to Frank Martello’s telephone, although the other pen registers were continued. In *410April 1992 an eavesdropping warrant was obtained for Melvin Goldsmith’s residential telephone.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.