Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit April 24, 1996, 96-8147 (Teper v. Miller)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-04-1996
HILL, Senior Circuit Judge, dissenting:
I dissent and I state my reason succinctly:1 "The fleas come with the dog."
First, there is no issue as to whether or not the federal law, FECA, preempts state
law. It does so, explicitly. Therefore, what federal law controls, state law may not.
That is not the end of the inquiry. The preemption is coextensive with FECA -
no more, no less. So, we should determine how far FECA goes. We may look to
legislative history to understand FECA.2
In Reeder v. Kansas City Bd. of Police Comm'rs, 733 F.2d 543 (8th Cir. 1984),
the Eighth Circuit did just that:
The conference report on the bill that became the 1974 amendment
leaves little room for doubt on this question. The report says:
It is the intent of the conferees that any State law
regulating the political activities of State and local
officers and employees is not preempted or superseded by
the amendments to title 5, United States Code, made by
this legislation.
S.Conf.Rep. No. 93-1237, 93d Cong., 2d Sess., reprinted in 1974
U.S.Code Cong. & Ad.News 5587, 5618, 5669. Furthermore, right
before the conference report was agreed to by the Senate, a colloquy
took place between Senator Stevens and Senator Cannon that covers
this very point. Senator Cannon was Chairman of the Committee of
1
Today, our panel's judgment does, in effect, release appellee Teper from
restraint of Georgia law. While I disagree, I realize that this judgment ought to be
mandated right away. I should not be the instrument of delay while engaging in
lengthy opinion writing. [NOTE: This was written and submitted while the Georgia
legislature was still in session.]
2
Briefs have argued, correctly, that we need not look to the legislative
history of this Act to determine preemption vel non. That is correct, but the extent
of the reach of FECA, and, therefore, just what it preempts, is not so clear.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit